John Astin

as Michael O'Toole

Pat Carroll

as Callie Burdyne

Hans Conried

as Polonius Vandergelt

Richard Erdman

as Judge Quincey P. Trumbell

Allyn Joslyn

as Sheriff Ed Hatfield

Richard Jury

as Harmon P. Lovejoy

Lee Meriwether

as Paloma Littleberry

Jesse White

as Mayor