John Leguizamo

as Michael Beltran

Katherine Waterston

as Shirley Lyner

Cynthia Nixon

as Gail Beltran

Andy Comeau

as Jerry Tuchman

Denis O'Hare

as Stan Lyner

Lauren Birkell

as Melissa Rowan

Louisa Krause

as Brenda Woodberg

Halley Wegryn Gross

as Nadine Woodberg