K.C. Clyde

as Elder John Rogers

Kirby Heyborne

as Elder Hezekiah Calhoun

Cameron Hopkin

as Elder Steven Van Pelt

David Nibley

as Elder Emmit Johnson

Scott Christopher

as Kyle Harrison

Michael Flynn

as President Sandburg

Ineke den Hollander

as Woman on Train

Jaime Anderson

as Elder Van Pelt's Girlfriend