Vincent Price

as Locke / Fortunato / Valdemar / Narrator

Peter Lorre

as Montresor ("The Black Cat")

Basil Rathbone

as Carmichael ("The Case of M. Valdemar")

Debra Paget

as Helene ("The Case of M. Valdemar")

Maggie Pierce

as Lenora ("Morella")

Joyce Jameson

as Annabel ("The Black Cat")

Leona Gage

as Morella ("Morella")

David Frankham

as Dr. James ("The Case of M. Valdemar")