Jacki Weaver

as Mary Baxter

Jess Weixler

as Austin Baxter

Stana Katic

as Carolina "Carol" Baxter Shaw

Michelle Trachtenberg

as Dallas Baxter

Troian Bellisario

as Baltimore Baxter

Alfred Molina

as Mort Stone

Kaia Gerber

as Young Carolina

Tom Everett Scott

as Chief Barton Brady