Guy Madison

as Marshal James Butler 'Wild Bill' Hickok

Andy Devine

as Aloysius P. 'Jingles' Jones

Kristine Miller

as Cindy Howard

Richard Avonde

as Dick Howard

John Crawford

as King Bradshaw

Tristram Coffin

as Mr. Otis, Lawyer

Edward Clark

as Grandpa Jeb Randall

Reed Howes

as Mr. Slate, Stagecoach Line Owner