Angelina Jolie

as Christine Collins

John Malkovich

as Rev. Gustav Briegleb

Jeffrey Donovan

as Captain J.J. Jones

Michael Kelly

as Detective Lester Ybarra

Colm Feore

as Chief James E. Davis

Jason Butler Harner

as Gordon Northcott

Amy Ryan

as Carol Dexter

Geoff Pierson

as S.S. Hahn